What to say first, what to say when they say "not now," and the moment to stop talking
You have practiced this on the drive down I-4 for a week, and the version you rehearsed opens with "I know budgets are tight." That line hands over the raise before you have made the request. Once you've made that offer with a smile, your manager has an easy exit ready to use. From there, the remainder of the meeting turns into you trying to recover ground you handed over without meaning to.
Many people begin by being easygoing and only later get down to specifics. To a manager, an accommodating tone usually registers as flexibility. A 2023 Berkeley Haas study found that 54% of women had negotiated their latest offer versus 44% of men, yet women still walked away with less pay. Asking is not the problem. Asking softly, with no figure and no date, is.
1. The opening line
It sounds natural but weak: "I know this might not be a good time, but I wanted to talk about compensation."
A more effective way to begin is: "I'd like to talk about my pay. In Orlando, the market midpoint for my position is X, and my current salary is Y. I'd like to close that gap this year."
Why: in two sentences you have given a number, a reference point and a timeframe. With that framing, your manager is haggling over an amount instead of wondering whether you're truly committed. Pay ranges are posted in a growing number of states, and the midpoint for your role can often be found in about thirty minutes.
2. Should they challenge you on whether you've earned the raise
Avoid something like: "I've worked really hard this year and taken on a lot."
SHORT Stronger: "Here are three reasons. Instead, say: "I took over the vendor renewal here in Orlando and saved the contract." Or: "I ran the integration two months ahead of schedule." Or: "I'm now managing two more direct reports than I was hired for."
The reason: effort alone is subjective. Renewals, delivery dates and headcount figures are what actually prove your value. With a case that concrete, your manager can carry it up the chain without having to build it from scratch, which you've already done for them.
3. If the reply is a flat "not now"
SHORT Weak: "I get it. Try something like: "Try something like: "Maybe we can revisit it later."
SHORT Stronger: "Noted. Ask instead: "What would need to be true for this to become a yes, and when can we book time to check that?"
The reason: "later" has no calendar date attached. A manager who is genuinely committed will lay out what must happen and set a specific month for review. If you hear "let's see" instead, you've still learned something valuable before the next review cycle in Central Florida or anywhere else.
4. If the offer lands below your request
Resist the urge to say: "Oh, that's great, thank you so much."
SHORT Stronger: "I appreciate that. That gets me partway. Say something like: "Thank you. Can we put a date on a plan to close the rest?"
SHORT The reason: showing appreciation is appropriate. Expressing thanks as a way to wrap things up gives away your leverage. You can accept the current figure while keeping the remaining gap open and documented, which is how gaps in Winter Park, Sanford or Kissimmee actually get closed.
5. The moment to stop talking
It's tempting to add: "And I'd also be happy to take on more if that helps, or we could look at title instead, or..."
Better: say your number. Stronger: state your figure. Then nothing.
The reason: quiet after a request can feel uncomfortable. Your manager feels that same pull, and whoever breaks the quiet first usually loses ground. Let it be them. Three seconds feels like a minute. Count them anyway.
The idea that ties all five together
Open with precise details such as figures, dates and proof, and add friendliness once those are on the table. A manager can't act on how you feel, and most would rather receive a solid case than an apology, since the case is what they'll need to take upstairs. The problem was never that women declined to negotiate. Negotiating without a figure was.
Pass this along to the colleague in Oviedo, Apopka or Lake Mary who mentioned she plans to raise it soon.